The practice of “The Role of Peer and Tutor” concept was
never really utilized during my 10 years of education in both Primary and
Secondary school. Most of my English teachers usually mark compositions mainly
on the content, grammar and spelling mistakes. Little or no constructive feedback are given to students to help them really understand the mistakes
made nor boost them to do better quality work. The teachers are also not that
approachable nor are they willing to spend more time in correcting mistakes of certain
weak students. Basically English lessons are based on assignments after
assignments and grades after grades.
Also in Polytechnic, I was given a similar module like
Effective Communication during my first semester upon being first year student
there. They do help students brush up a little on the grammars, teaching on how
to write a proper report and present effectively. But there is still not much
constructive feedback being put in practice and non-beneficial to me. Once you
sent the report to the lecturer, you will never see or know what happened to it
ever again.
However it was a different case in University with Effective
Communication module. We were forced to give our own opinions or feedback to
other fellow classmates in our first assignment. Then we would be given another feedback by Brad himself, who teaches the course. The opportunity to “Learn,
Unlearn and Relearn” English language and report writing is greatly ample and
well utilized.
By using the same assignment to improve on further from draft
after draft has made me more aware of the common mistakes or bad habits that I
may have in writing. Comments are also given for me to know more like example
why a certain sentence structure is wrong and it helps me to learn through such
reasoning. Also a one-to-one sessions are made available to further assist
students. I find this most effective as during this session, the main focus
will be on the student him/herself in terms of mistakes and letting them be
aware of the correct way of writing. In addition, general feedback on the
mistakes by fellow classmates are also discussed during class and this helps me
to learn to avoid it.
To be honest, I feel that I have slightly improve on my
command of English writing skills. While I do other reports or assignments, I am
more proactive in editing my reports over and over again. Also I tend to check
on the habitual mistakes I would make on reports and quickly improve them
further. Not only that, I would even consult other friends or classmates to
read on my writing and give me feedback on grammar and content. In all, I feel
that this module has greatly impact me to write better and be more receptive to feedback that helps to upgrade myself further. Having such enthusiastic and captivating tutor such as Brad himself has made learning English as well as the
Effective Communication module itself more interesting and enriching for not only
me but everyone.
Hey Sha Sha,
ReplyDeleteI totally agree with you that this module has greatly impacted me to write better and be more receptive to feedback too. It is really not easy giving feedbacks to your peers as i am there to learn. Indeed, all of us have benefited from Brad's lesson. It is quite sad that this will be the only module that we will be having with him. Thanks for all the feedback you have given me Sha.
Cheers,
Franklin
I really appreciate the detail in this post, Sha. You give a complete overview of how feedback was used (or not used) in your previous schooling. Then you discuss feedback in the context of SIE2016. I'm glad you seem to have responded well to the exercise. It also warms my heart when you give more accolades about my approach to teaching and learning.
ReplyDeleteMy only worry in this post is that you don't, technically speaking, follow the prescribed structure for a critical reflection (as we had discussed it). Remember the diagram that starts with "What happened" proceeds to "How do you feel about it" then moves to "What did you learn about yourself and others" and lands on "How will you use it to inform your future?"
In short, your post is very comprehensive, but there seems to be more emphasis on accolades and a shortage of the "critical" part. How did the feedback make you feel, when you were giving and receiving? Was there any problem with such feedback? Is it awkward to critique the work of classmates? Would you ever do that beyond eff comm class?
These issues truly interest me.
In any case, I really appreciate all your effort and the big smiles this term. Your inspired classroom attitude has helped make T5 a great group! Terima kasih!